WOODS OEM 57189KT (57189-2 Blade Set) 26 vs 50034235 PTO Shaft with Slip Clutch Driv
Quick Verdict
These two products serve completely different purposes, so the “winner” depends entirely on what you need. The WOODS 57189KT is a blade set for a 26.5-inch Brushbull Series rotary cutter, designed for mowing vegetation. The PTO Shaft is a driveline component with a slip clutch, intended for connecting a mower to a tractor’s power take-off. If you need replacement blades, choose WOODS. If you need a PTO shaft for a Bush Hog-style mower, choose the PTO shaft.
Side-by-Side
| Feature | WOODS 57189KT | 50034235 PTO Shaft |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $218.10 | $322.42 |
| Primary Function | Blade set (2 blades) for rotary cutter | PTO driveline with slip clutch |
| Cut Width | 26.5 inches (from product name) | Not applicable |
| Power Source | Tractor PTO (via mower deck) | Tractor PTO (connects mower to tractor) |
| Best For | Replacing blades on a 26.5" Brushbull mower | Replacing a PTO shaft on a Bush Hog or similar rotary cutter |
| Rating | 4.6/5 (61 reviews) | 4.7/5 (16 reviews) |
Where WOODS Wins
The WOODS blade set is the clear choice if you need to replace worn or damaged blades on a 26.5-inch Brushbull Series rotary cutter. At $218.10, it is significantly less expensive than the PTO shaft, and the high number of reviews (61) indicates broad user experience. The 4.6/5 rating suggests consistent quality and proper fit for the intended model. This product is a direct OEM replacement, so you can expect it to match the original blade specifications for cutting performance and durability.
Where PTO Wins
The PTO shaft is the only option if you need a driveline with a slip clutch for a Bush Hog or similar rotary cutter that requires a John Deere-compatible connection. The slip clutch is a critical safety and mechanical feature that protects the tractor and mower from shock loads during operation. At $322.42, it is more expensive, but it is a specialized component. The 4.7/5 rating from 16 reviews suggests high satisfaction among users who needed this specific part. Without a functioning PTO shaft, the mower cannot operate, making this a necessary replacement for broken or worn drivelines.
Which Should You Buy
Buy the WOODS 57189KT if: You own a 26.5-inch WOODS Brushbull Series rotary cutter and need to replace the blades. This is a straightforward purchase for routine maintenance. The lower price and high review count make it a reliable choice.
Buy the 50034235 PTO Shaft if: You need a replacement PTO driveline with a slip clutch for a Bush Hog or similar rotary cutter, especially one that fits a John Deere tractor. This is a specific mechanical component, not a blade set. Ensure your mower’s input shaft and tractor’s output shaft match the dimensions of this shaft before purchasing.
Do not buy either if: You are looking for a complete mower. These are replacement parts, not standalone machines. Also, do not buy the PTO shaft expecting it to work with a WOODS Brushbull mower unless you confirm compatibility, as WOODS and Bush Hog use different PTO shaft designs.