Scotts Outdoor Power Tools 716-18S 18-In vs Earthwise 1816-18EW 18-Inch 5-Blade Push

Quick Verdict

Both mowers are high-quality manual reel options for small to medium lawns, but the Scotts Outdoor Power Tools 716-18S edges ahead with a 7-blade cutting system that delivers a finer, more manicured cut. The Earthwise 1816-18EW is a solid, slightly more affordable choice that works well for basic maintenance. For most users seeking a cleaner cut and better performance on thicker grass, the Scotts is the winner. If budget is the primary concern and your lawn is consistently short, the Earthwise is a capable alternative.

Side-by-Side

Both mowers share the same 18-inch cutting width, making them suitable for similar lawn areas. The Scotts costs $13 more but offers two additional blades. The Earthwise is lighter on the wallet but has fewer blades, which affects cut quality.

Where Scotts Wins

The Scotts 716-18S wins on cut quality. Its 7-blade reel produces more cuts per rotation, resulting in a finer, more even trim. This is especially noticeable on thicker grass or when you want a golf-course-like appearance. The additional blades also help the mower handle slightly taller or denser grass without clogging or stalling as easily.

The Scotts also benefits from a stronger build and better customer feedback volume (5,926 reviews versus 1,765), indicating a longer track record and more user-validated reliability. The cutting height adjustments are straightforward, and the overall design feels more robust for regular use.

Where Earthwise Wins

The Earthwise 1816-18EW wins on price and simplicity. At $129.89, it is $13 cheaper, making it a more budget-friendly entry point into manual mowing. It is also slightly lighter, which can be an advantage for pushing on uneven terrain or for users who prefer a less heavy tool.

For lawns that are consistently kept short and free of thick weeds, the 5-blade system performs adequately. The Earthwise also has a reputation for being easy to assemble and maintain, with fewer moving parts to worry about. If you only need to trim a small, flat lawn weekly, the Earthwise will get the job done without overspending.

Which Should You Buy

Choose the Scotts 716-18S if: You want the best cut quality for a medium-sized lawn (up to 1/3 acre), you have thicker grass or occasional taller growth, and you are willing to spend a little more for a finer finish and proven reliability.

Choose the Earthwise 1816-18EW if: Your lawn is small (up to 1/4 acre), consistently short, and you want to save money. It is also a good choice if you prefer a lighter mower or are just trying manual mowing for the first time.

For most homeowners, the Scotts offers better long-term value due to its superior cutting performance and broader user satisfaction. The Earthwise is a capable lower-cost alternative for lighter duty.