Scotts Outdoor Power Tools 304-14S 14-In vs Earthwise 1715-16EW 16-Inch 7-Blade Push

Quick Verdict

Both mowers are solid reel mowers with identical 4.2/5 ratings, but they serve slightly different needs. The Earthwise 1715-16EW is the better value for larger lawns, offering a wider 16-inch cut and a 7-blade reel at a lower price. The Scotts Outdoor Power Tools 304-14S is a narrower, 5-blade mower that costs more but may appeal to those who prefer a lighter, more maneuverable tool for smaller spaces. For most buyers, the Earthwise wins on price and cutting width.

Side-by-Side

Where Scotts Wins

Higher review volume and proven reliability. With nearly 6,000 reviews, the Scotts has a larger user base, which often indicates a more established product. Many users report it’s easy to push and adjust, especially on flat, manicured lawns.

Lighter and more maneuverable. The 14-inch width and 5-blade design make the Scotts slightly lighter and easier to turn in tight spaces, such as around flower beds or garden edges. If your lawn has many obstacles or narrow paths, the Scotts may feel more agile.

Potentially better build quality. Some users note that the Scotts feels sturdier, with a metal cutting reel and a frame that holds up well over multiple seasons. The higher price may reflect slightly better materials or assembly.

Where Earthwise Wins

Wider cut for faster mowing. The 16-inch width means fewer passes to cover the same area, saving time on lawns that are larger or more open. Combined with 7 blades, the Earthwise can also produce a finer cut, especially on grass that’s not too tall or thick.

Lower price. At $114.06, the Earthwise is about $26 cheaper than the Scotts. For a reel mower, that’s a meaningful savings, especially if you’re on a budget or need to buy multiple mowers for a property.

Better for taller grass. The 7-blade reel provides more cutting action per rotation, which can handle slightly taller or denser grass than the 5-blade Scotts. Users report it cuts cleanly without as much effort, as long as the grass isn’t overly thick.

Which Should You Buy

Choose the Scotts 304-14S if: You have a small lawn (under 1/4 acre) with many obstacles, need a lighter mower for easy handling, or prefer a model with a large review base that suggests long-term reliability. It’s also a good pick if you value a more compact tool for storage.

Choose the Earthwise 1715-16EW if: You want the best value for money, have a lawn up to 1/3 acre, or need a wider cut to finish faster. The extra blade and lower price make it the smarter choice for most homeowners, especially those with slightly larger or moderately thick grass.

In short, the Earthwise offers more for less, but the Scotts is a proven performer for tight spaces.