Great States 815-18 18-Inch 5-Blade Push vs Earthwise 1816-18EW 18-Inch 5-Blade Push

Quick Verdict

Both mowers are 18-inch, 5-blade push reel mowers designed for small to medium lawns. The Great States 815-18 offers slightly better value at a lower price with a higher user rating, while the Earthwise 1816-18EW is a close competitor with a similar design and slightly higher cost. For most buyers, the Great States is the stronger choice due to its lower price and proven reliability, but the Earthwise is a solid alternative if you prefer its specific build or color.

Side-by-Side

Both mowers are nearly identical in width and blade count, making them suitable for similar lawn sizes. The Great States is slightly lighter and has a significantly larger review base, indicating broader use and satisfaction.

Where Great States Wins

The Great States 815-18 excels in value and user confidence. At $116.00, it is $13.89 cheaper than the Earthwise, yet it has a higher average rating (4.3 vs. 4.2) and over five times as many reviews. This large sample size suggests consistent performance and durability across many users. The mower is also 2 lbs lighter, which can reduce fatigue during longer mowing sessions. Its 5-blade reel provides a clean cut on grass up to 4 inches tall, and the hardened steel blades hold their edge well with regular maintenance. For budget-conscious buyers or those with small, flat lawns, the Great States offers proven reliability at a lower cost.

Where Earthwise Wins

The Earthwise 1816-18EW has a few subtle advantages. Its 30-lb frame feels slightly more substantial, which some users may prefer for stability on uneven ground. The mower features a slightly wider cutting path due to its blade design, though both are officially 18 inches. The Earthwise also includes a durable steel blade system with a 10-inch wheel size, which can roll over small bumps more smoothly. Its grey color and modern look may appeal to those who want a more contemporary appearance. Additionally, the Earthwise brand offers a 2-year warranty, which matches the Great States but may feel more accessible for customer support.

Which Should You Buy

Buy the Great States 815-18 if: You want the best value for money, prioritize a proven track record with thousands of positive reviews, or need a lightweight mower for a small, flat lawn. It is the smarter choice for most homeowners with lawns under 5,000 sq ft.

Buy the Earthwise 1816-18EW if: You prefer a slightly heavier, more stable feel, like the grey color, or want a mower with a slightly larger wheelbase for uneven terrain. It is a good alternative if the Great States is unavailable or if you find a deal that narrows the price gap.

For most buyers, the Great States 815-18 wins due to its lower price, higher rating, and broader user base. The Earthwise is a close second but does not justify its higher cost unless specific design or weight preferences apply.