Great States 204-14 Hand Reel 14 Inch Pu vs Earthwise 1314-14EW 14" 5-Blade Economy

Quick Verdict

For most buyers on a budget, the Great States 204-14 Hand Reel 14 Inch Push Lawn Mower is the better choice. It costs $20 less, has a slightly higher average rating from over five times as many reviews, and delivers a clean cut on small, level lawns. The Earthwise 1314-14EW 14" 5-Blade Economy Reel Mower is a strong alternative if you prefer a five-blade cutting system for a finer finish, but its higher price and lower review count make it a niche pick for users who prioritize blade count over value.

Side-by-Side

Where Great States Wins

Great States takes the lead in value and user confidence. At $89.99, it undercuts the Earthwise by $20, which is a meaningful savings on a manual reel mower. Its 4.3-star rating from nearly 10,000 reviews indicates consistent satisfaction across a broad user base. The four-blade design is lighter and easier to push on level ground, making it ideal for small lawns where simplicity and low maintenance matter. Great States also has a longer track record in the reel mower market, so replacement parts and accessories are more widely available. For someone who just needs a reliable, no-fuss mower for a modest lawn, this model delivers the same 14-inch cut width at a lower cost.

Where Earthwise Wins

Earthwise’s key advantage is its five-blade cutting reel. More blades mean more cuts per rotation, which produces a finer, more manicured finish—especially important if you want a golf-green look on a small, flat lawn. The 1314-14EW also tends to handle slightly taller grass with less strain because the extra blades distribute the cutting load. Additionally, Earthwise often includes better assembly guides and customer support for first-time reel mower users. If you have a tiny, perfectly level yard and are willing to pay extra for a smoother cut, the five-blade design is a tangible upgrade over the Great States’ four-blade system.

Which Should You Buy

Choose the Great States 204-14 if you want the best value for a small, flat lawn. It costs less, has proven reliability from a massive number of reviews, and cuts well enough for most homeowners. It’s the practical choice for anyone who doesn’t need a show-quality finish.

Choose the Earthwise 1314-14EW if you’re willing to spend $20 more for a finer cut and slightly better performance in thicker grass. It’s a better fit for lawn enthusiasts who mow frequently and want a cleaner appearance, provided their yard is small and level.

In short: Great States wins on price and trust; Earthwise wins on blade count and cut quality. For the vast majority of buyers, Great States is the smarter buy.