CRAFTSMAN 42" Gas Riding Lawn Mower with vs Husqvarna 581071001 Lawn Tractor 46-in D
Quick Verdict
The Husqvarna 581071001 offers a better value with a lower price, higher user rating, and larger cutting deck. However, the Craftsman 42" model is a solid choice for those who prefer a slightly smaller, potentially more maneuverable machine from a widely available brand. For most buyers with a standard lawn, the Husqvarna is the stronger pick.
Side-by-Side
| Feature | Craftsman 42" Gas Riding Mower | Husqvarna 581071001 Lawn Tractor |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $2,099.00 | $1,800.00 |
| Engine | 17.5 HP* Briggs & Stratton | Not specified in title (Husqvarna typically uses Kawasaki or Briggs) |
| Cut Width | 42 inches | 46 inches |
| User Rating | 4.2/5 (166 reviews) | 4.6/5 (130 reviews) |
| Best Yard Size | 1–2 acres | 1.5–3 acres |
Where Craftsman Wins
The Craftsman 42" mower has two key advantages. First, its 17.5 HP* Briggs & Stratton engine is a known, widely serviced powerplant. If you need repairs or parts, Briggs & Stratton dealers are common. Second, the 42-inch deck is lighter and narrower than the Husqvarna’s 46-inch deck. This makes the Craftsman more maneuverable in smaller, tighter yards with lots of obstacles like trees, flower beds, or narrow gates. For a yard under 1.5 acres with complex landscaping, the smaller cut width can save time on trimming and reduce the risk of scalping.
Where Husqvarna Wins
The Husqvarna 581071001 wins on three fronts: price, cut width, and user satisfaction. At $1,800, it is $299 cheaper than the Craftsman while offering a larger 46-inch deck. This wider cut reduces mowing time on open lawns, making it better suited for properties of 2 acres or more. The 4.6/5 rating from 130 reviews (vs. 4.2/5 from 166) indicates higher owner satisfaction—likely due to better build quality, smoother operation, or longer lifespan. Husqvarna also has a strong reputation for durable frames and reliable transmissions, which matters for long-term ownership.
Which Should You Buy
Choose the Craftsman if:
- Your yard is under 1.5 acres and has many tight turns, narrow passages, or complex landscaping.
- You prefer a widely available engine brand (Briggs & Stratton) for easier local service.
- You are willing to pay a premium for the 42-inch deck’s maneuverability.
Choose the Husqvarna if:
- Your yard is 1.5 acres or larger and relatively open, where a 46-inch deck saves time.
- You want the best value for money—lower price, higher user rating, and bigger cut.
- You prioritize long-term reliability and higher owner satisfaction based on review data.
For most homeowners with a typical 1–2 acre lot, the Husqvarna is the better buy. It costs less, cuts wider, and has a stronger reputation. The Craftsman only wins if you specifically need a smaller, more nimble machine for a tight yard.