American Lawn Mower Company vs Lawn Mower Wheel Sulky, Walk Behind Mowe
Quick Verdict
The American Lawn Mower Company product is a clear winner in this head-to-head comparison. It is a reliable, well-reviewed manual reel mower with over 22,000 ratings and a strong 4.3/5 average. The other product is a sulky attachment (a riding platform for a walk-behind mower), not a mower itself. With only 29 reviews and a low 2.5/5 rating, it is a niche accessory with poor user satisfaction. For anyone needing an actual lawn mower, the American Lawn Mower Company model is the obvious choice.
Side-by-Side
| Feature | American Lawn Mower Company | Lawn Mower Wheel Sulky |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $119.99 | $99.99 |
| Type | Manual reel mower | Sulky attachment (not a mower) |
| Power | Human-powered (no engine) | N/A |
| Cut Width | Not specified in title (typically 14–20" for this brand) | N/A |
| Reviews | 22,499 (4.3/5) | 29 (2.5/5) |
| Best Yard Size | Small to medium (under 1/4 acre) | Only for use with an existing walk-behind mower |
Where American Lawn Mower Wins
This product wins on virtually every relevant metric. It is a fully functional lawn mower, designed to cut grass cleanly without gas, oil, or noise. With over 22,000 reviews and a 4.3/5 rating, it has proven reliability and broad user satisfaction. Its low price of $119.99 makes it one of the most affordable mowing solutions available. It is ideal for small, flat yards and delivers a quiet, eco-friendly cut that is good for the lawn (reel mowers slice grass rather than tearing it). It also requires minimal maintenance—just occasional blade sharpening.
Where Sulky Wins
The sulky attachment only wins if you already own a compatible walk-behind mower and want to ride instead of walk. Its lower price of $99.99 is the only advantage. However, the 2.5/5 rating from just 29 reviews indicates widespread dissatisfaction—likely due to poor build quality, difficulty attaching, or uncomfortable riding. It is not a mower and cannot cut grass on its own. It also requires a separate mower investment, making the total cost much higher.
Which Should You Buy
Buy the American Lawn Mower Company reel mower. It is a proven, affordable, and effective tool for cutting grass in small yards. The sulky attachment is a poor choice for most people: it has a low rating, few reviews, and does not perform the basic function of mowing. Only consider the sulky if you already own a specific walk-behind mower and are willing to risk an accessory with a 2.5/5 rating. For anyone else, the American Lawn Mower Company product is the clear, sensible purchase.