American Lawn Mower Company vs Lawn Mower Wheel Sulky, Walk Behind Mowe
Quick Verdict
These two products serve entirely different purposes, which makes a direct comparison somewhat misleading. The American Lawn Mower Company product is a reel mower designed for cutting grass, while the Lawn Mower Wheel Sulky is an attachment that allows you to ride behind a walk-behind mower. If you need a mower to cut your lawn, the American Lawn Mower is the clear choice. If you already own a walk-behind mower and want to convert it to a ride-on, the Sulky is the only option between the two. Based on price, ratings, and intended use, the American Lawn Mower Company mower wins for most buyers.
Side-by-Side
| Feature | American Lawn Mower Company | Lawn Mower Wheel Sulky |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $141.18 | $99.99 |
| Rating | 3.9/5 (709 reviews) | 2.5/5 (29 reviews) |
| Power | Manual (reel / push) | None (attachment) |
| Cut Width | Not specified in title, but typical models are 14–20 inches | Not applicable |
| Best Yard Size | Small to medium (up to 1/4 acre) | Any size (depends on mower) |
The American Lawn Mower is a complete mower; the Sulky is an accessory that requires a separate mower to function.
Where American Lawn Mower Wins
- Complete solution: It is a fully functional reel mower that cuts grass without gas, electricity, or noise. You can use it immediately after assembly.
- Customer confidence: With 709 reviews and a 3.9 rating, it has been widely tested. The Sulky has only 29 reviews and a low 2.5 rating, suggesting quality or compatibility issues.
- Eco-friendly & quiet: Manual reel mowers produce no emissions and are very quiet, making them ideal for early morning or late evening mowing.
- Low maintenance: No engine, no oil changes, no spark plugs. Sharpening the reel is the only regular upkeep.
- Cost-effective for small yards: At $141, it is a one-time purchase with no ongoing fuel costs.
Where Sulky Wins
- Ride-on capability: If you have a large yard and already own a walk-behind mower, the Sulky lets you ride instead of walk, reducing physical effort.
- Lower price: At $99.99, it is cheaper than the American Lawn Mower, but only if you already have a compatible mower.
- Potential time saver: For very large properties, riding can be faster than pushing, especially if your mower is self-propelled.
However, the Sulky’s low rating and limited reviews suggest it may be difficult to attach, unstable, or poorly built. Many users report wobbling, poor turning, and difficulty with uneven terrain.
Which Should You Buy
Buy the American Lawn Mower Company mower if you need to cut grass and have a small to medium lawn (under 1/4 acre). It is a reliable, quiet, and low-maintenance tool that does exactly what a mower should do. The high review count and decent rating indicate it works well for most users.
Only consider the Lawn Mower Wheel Sulky if you already own a compatible walk-behind mower and are willing to risk a low-rated product. Even then, read recent reviews carefully to ensure it fits your specific mower model. For most people, the American Lawn Mower is the better purchase.