American Lawn Mower Company vs Lawn Mower Wheel Sulky, Walk Behind Mowe
Quick Verdict
These two products serve entirely different purposes, making a direct head-to-head comparison misleading. The American Lawn Mower Company is a reel mower designed for cutting grass, while the Sulky is an attachment—a riding platform—for an existing walk-behind mower. If you need a mower to cut grass, the American Lawn Mower Company is the obvious choice. If you already own a walk-behind mower and want to ride instead of walk, the Sulky is a low-cost option, but its poor reviews and low rating suggest significant quality or usability issues.
Side-by-Side
| Feature | American Lawn Mower Company | Lawn Mower Wheel Sulky |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $159.99 | $99.99 |
| Power | Manual (push reel) | None (attachment) |
| Cut Width | Not specified in title; typical for this brand is 14–20 inches | N/A |
| Best Yard Size | Small to medium (up to 1/4 acre) | N/A (depends on mower it attaches to) |
| Rating | 3.9/5 (709 reviews) | 2.5/5 (29 reviews) |
The table highlights that these are not competitors. The American mower is a standalone tool; the Sulky is an accessory.
Where American Lawn Mower Wins
The American Lawn Mower Company wins in every category relevant to mowing. It is a complete, functional mower with a strong reputation, backed by nearly 710 reviews and a solid 3.9-star average. It requires no fuel, no electricity, and minimal maintenance—just sharpening the reel blades occasionally. It is quiet, lightweight, and environmentally friendly. For small, flat lawns, it provides a clean, scissor-like cut that is healthier for grass than a rotary blade. The price is reasonable for a well-reviewed manual mower.
Where Sulky Wins
The Sulky wins only in the narrow scenario where you already own a walk-behind mower and want to reduce walking fatigue. At $99.99, it is cheaper than buying a riding mower or a new self-propelled model. It attaches to the back of a standard walk-behind mower, allowing you to ride while mowing. However, the extremely low rating (2.5/5) and small sample size (29 reviews) indicate that many users find it flimsy, difficult to attach, or prone to tipping. It does not cut grass itself, so it is not a mower in any sense.
Which Should You Buy
Buy the American Lawn Mower Company if you need a mower for a small, flat lawn. It is a proven product at a fair price, and the large number of positive reviews gives confidence in its performance and durability. It is ideal for homeowners who want a quiet, low-maintenance, and eco-friendly option.
Do not buy the Sulky unless you already own a walk-behind mower and are willing to risk a poorly-reviewed attachment. Even then, consider spending more on a higher-rated sulky or a used riding mower. The Sulky’s low rating and limited reviews suggest it may not be a reliable or safe addition to your mowing setup. If you are choosing between these two for mowing grass, the American Lawn Mower Company is the only logical pick.