American Lawn Mower Company vs Ariens / Gravely Lawn Mower 42" Mulch Ki
Quick Verdict
The American Lawn Mower Company mower wins for small, flat yards where a simple, affordable reel mower is sufficient. The Ariens/Gravely 42" Mulch Kit is not a mower but a mower attachment, so it only wins for owners of compatible ZT-X zero-turn mowers who need a mulching upgrade. If you are buying a complete mower, the American Lawn Mower is the clear choice. If you already own the base mower, the Ariens kit is the necessary add-on.
Side-by-Side
| Feature | American Lawn Mower Company | Ariens/Gravely 42" Mulch Kit |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $167.59 | $205.95 |
| Power | Manual (push reel) | N/A (attachment; requires ZT-X mower) |
| Cut Width | Not in title (typically 14–20") | 42 inches |
| Best Yard Size | Small (under 1/4 acre) | Medium to large (over 1/2 acre) |
| Type | Complete mower | Mulch kit accessory |
Note: The Ariens/Gravely product is a mulching kit, not a standalone mower. It fits ZT-X and select Gravely zero-turn models.
Where American Lawn Mower Wins
- Complete mower: You get a ready-to-use reel mower for $167.59. No additional equipment is needed.
- No fuel or electricity: Manual push operation means zero emissions, near-silent mowing, and no maintenance for engines or batteries.
- Better for small lawns: Ideal for flat, well-maintained grass under 1/4 acre. Lightweight and easy to store.
- Higher rating: 4.0/5 from 88 reviews suggests consistent user satisfaction for its intended use.
- Price: Lower upfront cost by nearly $40.
Where Ariens Wins
- Faster mowing: The 42-inch cut width (when attached to a compatible ZT-X mower) covers much more ground per pass than any push reel mower.
- Mulching performance: Designed specifically to chop clippings finely and return nutrients to the lawn. For owners of the base mower, this kit improves grass health and eliminates bagging.
- Better for larger yards: If you have over 1/2 acre and already own a ZT-X, this kit makes mulching efficient.
- Durability: Ariens/Gravely components are built for commercial-grade use, lasting many seasons with proper care.
Which Should You Buy
Buy the American Lawn Mower Company mower if:
- You need a complete, low-cost mower for a small, flat lawn.
- You prefer manual, quiet, emission-free mowing.
- You do not already own a compatible ZT-X zero-turn mower.
Buy the Ariens/Gravely 42" Mulch Kit if:
- You already own a ZT-X or compatible Gravely zero-turn mower.
- You want to convert your mower from side-discharge or bagging to mulching.
- Your yard is medium to large and you need a 42-inch cutting width.
Do not buy the Ariens kit if you do not have the compatible base mower – it will not function on its own. For most buyers, the American Lawn Mower Company product is the practical, complete solution.