American Lawn Mower Company vs 50" Lawn Mower Deck Rebuild Kit for Cub
Quick Verdict
These two products serve entirely different purposes, making a direct head-to-head comparison unusual. The American Lawn Mower Company option is a complete, ready-to-use mower, while the Cub Cadet/MTD Rebuild Kit is a replacement parts set for an existing machine. If you need a new mower, the American Lawn Mower is the clear choice. If you already own a compatible Cub Cadet or MTD zero-turn with a 50-inch deck and need to restore cutting performance, the rebuild kit is the practical, cost-effective option.
Side-by-Side
| Feature | American Lawn Mower Company | Cub Cadet/MTD Rebuild Kit |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $159.99 | $126.99 |
| Power | Manual push (no engine) | N/A (replacement parts) |
| Cut Width | Not specified in title | 50 inches |
| Best Yard Size | Small, flat lawns (under 1/4 acre) | Medium to large lawns (requires compatible 50" zero-turn) |
| Type | Complete reel mower | Deck rebuild kit (spindles, blades, pulleys, etc.) |
| User Rating | 4.0/5 (3,799 reviews) | 4.4/5 (55 reviews) |
Where American Lawn Mower Wins
The American Lawn Mower Company product wins in immediate usability and low ownership cost. It is a complete, manual reel mower that requires no fuel, oil, or electricity—just human power. It is lightweight, quiet, and virtually maintenance-free beyond blade sharpening. With nearly 3,800 reviews, it has a proven track record for small, flat lawns. It is also significantly cheaper than any powered mower and eliminates ongoing expenses for gas or batteries.
Where Cub Cadet Wins
The Cub Cadet/MTD Rebuild Kit wins for owners of compatible 50-inch zero-turn mowers who need to restore cutting performance without buying a new machine. At $126.99, it is likely much cheaper than dealer service or a new mower deck. The 50-inch cut width is ideal for larger properties where speed and efficiency matter. The kit typically includes critical wear items like spindles, blades, and pulleys, extending the life of an expensive piece of equipment. Its higher user rating (4.4 vs. 4.0) suggests strong satisfaction among those who need it.
Which Should You Buy
Choose the American Lawn Mower Company product if:
- You need a complete, ready-to-use mower right now
- Your lawn is small (under 1/4 acre), flat, and free of tall weeds
- You prefer manual, quiet, low-maintenance operation
- You want the lowest possible upfront and ongoing cost
Choose the Cub Cadet/MTD Rebuild Kit if:
- You already own a Cub Cadet, MTD, or compatible zero-turn mower with a 50-inch deck (models like RZT-50, ZT-5000)
- Your current mower has worn spindles, dull blades, or failing pulleys
- You want to restore cutting performance for $127 rather than buy a new mower
- You have a medium to large lawn and need the speed of a 50-inch zero-turn
In summary: buy the American mower if you have nothing to mow with yet. Buy the rebuild kit if you have a compatible zero-turn that needs parts. They are not direct competitors—they solve different problems.