American Lawn Mower Company vs 46 Inch Deck Rebuild Kit Fit Cub Cadet L
Quick Verdict
These are not comparable products. The American Lawn Mower Company offering is a complete, ready-to-use reel mower, while the Cub Cadet listing is a replacement deck rebuild kit for a riding mower. If you need a new mower for a small, flat lawn, the American reel mower is the obvious choice. If you already own a compatible Cub Cadet, Craftsman, or MTD riding mower (models like LTX1045 or LTX1046) and need a replacement cutting deck, the rebuild kit is the correct part. There is no direct head-to-head competition here.
Side-by-Side
| Feature | American Lawn Mower | Cub Cadet Rebuild Kit |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $141.18 | $104.99 |
| Power Source | Manual (push reel) | Requires riding mower |
| Cut Width (from title) | Not listed (typically 14–20") | 46 inches |
| Best Yard Size | Small, flat yards under 0.25 acre | Large yards (1+ acres) with compatible tractor |
| Customer Rating | 3.9/5 (709 reviews) | 4.3/5 (61 reviews) |
| What You Get | Complete mower, ready to use | Deck shell, spindle assemblies, blades, pulleys, hardware (no tractor) |
Where American Lawn Mower Wins
The American Lawn Mower Company product is the winner for anyone who needs a simple, affordable, and quiet mower for a small lawn. It requires no gas, oil, or battery, and it provides a clean, scissor-like cut that is healthier for grass. At $141.18, it is a complete solution—no additional purchases needed. It is lightweight, easy to maneuver, and low maintenance (just occasional blade sharpening). The high review count (709) indicates a well-established product with proven reliability. For homeowners with small, flat yards who want a quiet, eco-friendly option, this is the clear choice.
Where Cub Cadet Wins
The Cub Cadet rebuild kit wins if you already own a compatible riding mower with a worn or damaged 46-inch deck. At $104.99, it is significantly cheaper than buying a new mower or a factory OEM deck. The 4.3/5 rating from 61 reviews suggests satisfied customers who found the kit to be a good value and a reasonable fit. It includes all the major components needed to restore cutting performance: a new deck shell, spindles, blades, and pulleys. This is a cost-effective repair solution for owners of Cub Cadet LTX1045, LTX1046, Craftsman, or MTD models with a 46-inch deck. It does not make sense to buy this unless you already have the tractor.
Which Should You Buy
Buy the American Lawn Mower Company reel mower if: You need a new walk-behind mower for a small, flat lawn (under 0.25 acre). You want a quiet, manual, low-maintenance machine that costs under $150 and is ready to use out of the box.
Buy the Cub Cadet 46-inch deck rebuild kit if: You already own a compatible Cub Cadet, Craftsman, or MTD riding mower (with a 46-inch deck) that needs a new cutting deck. You are comfortable with mechanical work (or hiring someone) to install the kit. This is a repair part, not a standalone mower.
Do not buy either if: You need a gas or electric walk-behind mower for a medium-sized yard. The American reel mower is too small and requires too much effort for larger lawns, and the Cub Cadet kit is useless without a tractor.