American Lawn Mower Company 2415-16 16-I vs Great States 204-14 Hand Reel 14 Inch Pu

Quick Verdict

For most homeowners with small, flat lawns, the American Lawn Mower Company 2415-16 is the better choice. Its wider 16-inch cut, five-blade design, and higher average rating across a much larger sample of reviews make it a more reliable, efficient option for typical suburban yards. The Great States 204-14 is a solid budget pick for very small spaces, but its narrower 14-inch cut and four-blade reel mean more passes and longer mowing time.

Side-by-Side

The 16-inch width allows you to cover roughly 14% more grass per pass compared to the 14-inch model, which adds up noticeably on a 5,000 sq ft lawn.

Where American Lawn Mower Wins

• Wider cutting path: The 16-inch swath reduces mowing time and the number of passes needed, especially on lawns approaching 1/4 acre.
• Five-blade reel: More blades per revolution produce a finer, cleaner cut, which is better for grass health and appearance. This design also handles slightly taller or thicker grass without clogging as easily.
• Proven reliability at scale: With over 22,000 reviews and a 4.3 average, the 2415-16 has demonstrated consistent quality across a huge user base. This volume of feedback gives you more confidence in long-term performance.
• Better value per inch of cut: At $109.99 for 16 inches, you pay about $6.87 per inch of cutting width. The Great States costs $6.43 per inch, but the American mower’s extra blade and wider path deliver more utility for the small price premium.

Where Great States Wins

• Lower upfront cost: At $89.99, it saves you $20 compared to the American mower. If your budget is tight, this is the more affordable entry point.
• Lighter weight and easier handling: The 14-inch model is typically a few pounds lighter, making it slightly easier to push and maneuver in very tight spaces, such as narrow side yards or around flower beds.
• Adequate for tiny lawns: For a lawn under 2,000 sq ft, the 14-inch cut is sufficient, and the lighter build reduces fatigue during quick trims.
• Simple, classic design: The Great States design has been around for decades, and replacement parts (blades, wheels) are widely available and inexpensive.

Which Should You Buy

Buy the American Lawn Mower Company 2415-16 if:

• Your lawn is between 2,000 and 10,000 sq ft (up to 1/4 acre).
• You want a cleaner cut and fewer passes per mowing session.
• You prefer a mower with a larger review base that indicates long-term durability.
• You’re willing to spend an extra $20 for a 16-inch cutting width and a five-blade reel.

Buy the Great States 204-14 if:

• Your lawn is under 2,000 sq ft (very small yard or strip).
• You need the lowest possible price and don’t mind a narrower cut.
• You prioritize lightweight handling for tight,