American Lawn Mower Company 2415-16 16-I vs Earthwise 1816-18EW 18-Inch 5-Blade Push
Quick Verdict
For most homeowners with small, flat lawns, the American Lawn Mower Company 2415-16 is the better value. It offers a proven design, a lower price, and a strong track record based on user volume. The Earthwise 1816-18EW edges ahead if you need a wider cutting path to reduce passes on a slightly larger yard, but its higher cost and fewer reviews make it a narrower choice.
Side-by-Side
| Feature | American Lawn Mower 2415-16 | Earthwise 1816-18EW |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $109.99 | $129.89 |
| Power | Manual reel (5-blade) | Manual reel (5-blade) |
| Cut Width | 16 inches | 18 inches |
| Best Yard Size | Up to 1/4 acre | 1/4 to 1/3 acre |
| User Rating | 4.3/5 (22,499 reviews) | 4.2/5 (1,765 reviews) |
| Weight (approx.) | ~22 lbs | ~25 lbs |
Both are push reel mowers—no engine, no battery. The key difference is the 2-inch wider cutting deck on the Earthwise, which slightly reduces mowing time. The American model is lighter and significantly more reviewed, indicating a longer production history and broader user base.
Where American Lawn Mower Wins
- Price: At $20 less, the 2415-16 is the budget-friendly option without sacrificing core cutting performance.
- Proven Reliability: With over 22,000 reviews, this mower has been tested across countless conditions. Users consistently report durable steel construction and easy assembly.
- Lighter Weight: At roughly 22 lbs, it’s slightly easier to push and maneuver around flower beds or tight corners.
- Adjustable Cutting Height: The 2415-16 offers multiple height settings (typically 1–2.5 inches) via a simple lever, giving you flexibility for different grass types.
- Customer Support: American Lawn Mower Company has a long history in reel mowers, and replacement parts (blades, wheels) are widely available.
Where Earthwise Wins
- Wider Cut: The 18-inch deck covers more ground per pass, making it better for lawns near the 1/3-acre mark. You’ll finish mowing in fewer trips.
- Slightly Higher Build Quality: Some users note the Earthwise has a sturdier frame and thicker gauge steel, which may resist bending on uneven terrain.
- Better for Taller Grass: The wider wheels and slightly higher blade clearance can handle grass up to 4–5 inches without jamming as often as the American model.
- Ergonomic Handle: The Earthwise features a foam-wrapped handle that reduces vibration and hand fatigue during longer mowing sessions.
- Newer Design: With fewer reviews, the Earthwise represents a more modern take on the reel mower, incorporating minor improvements like a more efficient blade alignment system.
Which Should You Buy
Choose the American Lawn Mower 2415-16 if you have a small lawn (under 1/4 acre), want to save money, and prioritize a well-documented, reliable product with easy access to parts. It’s ideal for flat, well-maintained grass and for buyers who value a lower upfront cost and proven user satisfaction.
Choose the Earthwise 1816-18EW if your lawn is closer to 1/3 acre, you want to reduce mowing time with the wider cut, or you frequently deal with slightly taller grass. Pay the extra $20 for better ergonomics and a sturdier frame if you expect rougher terrain or longer mowing sessions.
For most buyers, the American Lawn