American Lawn Mower Company 2415-16 16-I vs Earthwise 1314-14EW 14" 5-Blade Economy

Quick Verdict

Both mowers are manual reel models priced identically at $109.99, but they target slightly different use cases. The American Lawn Mower Company 2415-16 wins for larger, more established lawns thanks to its wider 16-inch cutting path and higher user rating. The Earthwise 1314-14EW is better suited for smaller yards or budget-conscious buyers who prioritize a lighter, more maneuverable tool, though it has a narrower 14-inch cut.

Side-by-Side

Where American Lawn Mower Wins

The American Lawn Mower 2415-16 has a clear advantage in cutting width. Its 16-inch reel covers more ground per pass, reducing mowing time on medium-sized lawns (up to about 5,000 sq. ft.). The larger cutting swath also makes it more effective on uneven terrain, as the wider frame provides better stability. With over 22,000 reviews and a 4.3-star rating, it has a proven track record of reliability and user satisfaction. The 5-blade design delivers a cleaner cut on standard turf grasses like fescue and bluegrass, and the steel construction feels more durable over multiple seasons. For anyone with a lawn larger than a postage stamp, the extra two inches of width translate to noticeably fewer passes.

Where Earthwise Wins

The Earthwise 1314-14EW excels in tight spaces and lighter use. Its 14-inch cutting width makes it more maneuverable around flower beds, narrow pathways, and small urban lawns. The slightly lighter frame (about 25 lbs vs. the American’s 30 lbs) is easier to push on slopes or for users with less upper body strength. It also has a lower-profile design that slides under low-hanging shrubs or deck edges more easily. For lawns under 3,000 sq. ft., the narrower cut is less of a drawback, and the price match means you’re not paying extra for a smaller tool. The 4.2-star rating is still strong, and the fewer reviews suggest a newer or less popular model, but build quality is comparable for the price point.

Which Should You Buy

Choose the American Lawn Mower 2415-16 if your lawn is 3,000–5,000 sq. ft., relatively flat, and you want to finish mowing faster. The extra width and higher review count make it the safer bet for typical suburban yards. It’s also better if you plan to mow less frequently, as the wider reel handles slightly taller grass without clogging.

Choose the Earthwise 1314-14EW if your yard is under 3,000 sq. ft., has many obstacles, or if you value lighter weight and easier storage. It’s also a good pick for beginners or those who want a simple, no-fuss mower for a small, well-maintained lawn. Avoid it if you have thick St. Augustine or Bermuda grass, as the narrower reel may struggle with dense growth.

In summary: for most buyers, the American Lawn Mower offers better value per dollar due to its wider cut and