American Lawn Mower Company 1815-18 18-I vs Scotts Outdoor Power Tools 716-18S 18-In
Quick Verdict
For most homeowners with small to medium lawns, the American Lawn Mower Company 1815-18 is the better choice. It offers a slightly higher user rating (4.3 vs. 4.2) across a much larger review base (22,498 vs. 5,926), indicating consistent reliability. The Scotts 716-18S has two more blades (7 vs. 5), which can provide a finer cut on shorter grass, but its lower rating and smaller review sample suggest less proven performance overall.
Side-by-Side
| Feature | American Lawn Mower 1815-18 | Scotts 716-18S |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $141.98 | $142.89 |
| Blade Count | 5 | 7 |
| Cut Width | 18 inches | 18 inches |
| Best Yard Size | Up to 5,000 sq ft | Up to 4,000 sq ft |
| User Rating | 4.3/5 (22,498 reviews) | 4.2/5 (5,926 reviews) |
Both mowers are manual reel (push) models with an 18-inch cutting width, making them suitable for level, well-maintained lawns. The price difference is negligible ($0.91).
Where American Lawn Mower Wins
Proven reliability and ease of use. The American Lawn Mower 1815-18 has been on the market longer and benefits from a massive user base. Its 5-blade design is easier to push through thicker grass and requires less frequent sharpening than a 7-blade reel. The blades are also simpler to adjust and replace. For lawns with occasional taller grass or uneven spots, the 5-blade reel is more forgiving—it won’t clog as easily and requires less force to turn. The higher overall rating and sheer number of reviews indicate that this mower delivers consistent results for a wider range of users.
Where Scotts Wins
Finer cut quality on short, manicured grass. The Scotts 716-18S has seven blades, which means each rotation of the reel makes more cuts. This results in a smoother, more evenly sheared grass blade—ideal for Bermuda or Zoysia lawns kept under 2 inches tall. If you mow frequently (every 3–4 days) and want a golf-green appearance, the 7-blade design will produce a noticeably cleaner finish. The Scotts also has a slightly lower price point, though the difference is minimal.
Which Should You Buy
Choose the American Lawn Mower 1815-18 if:
- Your lawn is 3,000–5,000 sq ft with mixed grass types
- You sometimes let the grass get a little tall between mowings
- You want a mower that is easy to push and maintain
- You value a proven product with a large, satisfied user base
Choose the Scotts 716-18S if:
- Your lawn is small (under 4,000 sq ft) and kept very short
- You mow frequently and prioritize a precise, clean cut
- You are experienced with reel mowers and don’t mind slightly higher rolling resistance
For most buyers, the American Lawn Mower 1815-18 offers the best balance of ease, reliability, and value. The Scotts is a niche tool for those who want the absolute finest cut on a well-manicured lawn.