American Lawn Mower Company 1815-18 18-I vs Great States 304-14 14-Inch 5-Blade Push
Quick Verdict
The American Lawn Mower Company 1815-18 wins for larger, more open lawns where cutting width and efficiency matter. The Great States 304-14 is the better choice for smaller yards, tighter budgets, and users who prioritize lighter weight and easier storage. Both are manual reel mowers, so neither requires gas or electricity, but their differences in size and price make them suited to distinctly different users.
Side-by-Side
| Feature | American Lawn Mower 1815-18 | Great States 304-14 |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $141.98 | $94.99 |
| Number of Blades | 5 | 5 |
| Cutting Width | 18 inches | 14 inches |
| Best Yard Size | Up to 1/2 acre | Up to 1/4 acre |
| Power Source | Manual (push) | Manual (push) |
| Weight | ~27 lbs | ~18 lbs |
Where American Lawn Mower Wins
The American Lawn Mower Company model has a clear advantage in cutting width. With an 18-inch swath, it covers 28% more ground per pass than the 14-inch Great States mower. This reduces mowing time noticeably on lawns larger than 2,000 square feet. The wider cut also means fewer passes, which reduces walking distance and physical effort over a full mowing session.
The 1815-18 is generally rated as more durable for regular use on thicker grass. Its build includes a heavier steel frame and larger wheels, which improve stability on uneven terrain. For yards with Bermuda, fescue, or other common turfgrasses, the extra width and weight help the blades spin more consistently through thicker patches. The higher price reflects these size and durability advantages, making it the better long-term investment for someone mowing a medium-sized lawn weekly.
Where Great States Wins
The Great States 304-14 is significantly less expensive—$47 less than the American model. That price difference is meaningful for budget-conscious buyers or those mowing a very small lawn where the extra width offers little time savings.
At roughly 18 pounds, the Great States is about 9 pounds lighter than the American mower. This makes it easier to carry to a shed, lift over obstacles, or maneuver in tight spaces like garden beds or between trees. The narrower 14-inch cut is actually an advantage in small, irregularly shaped yards where a wider mower would have trouble turning or trimming close to edges.
The Great States also tends to require less storage space. Its compact frame fits into smaller garages or garden sheds without taking up floor area. For a townhouse patio or a lawn under 1,500 square feet, the lighter weight and lower cost make this the more practical choice.
Which Should You Buy
Choose the American Lawn Mower Company 1815-18 if your lawn is larger than 2,500 square feet, has relatively open areas, and you plan to mow regularly throughout the season. The wider cut will save you time, and the heavier build will hold up better over years of use. It is also the better option if you prefer fewer passes and don’t mind paying more for a larger mower.
Choose the Great States 304-14 if your lawn is small (under 2,500 square feet), has many obstacles, or if you need to carry the mower up stairs or into storage. It is also the smarter buy if you are on a tight budget or mow infrequently and want a simple, low-maintenance tool. The lighter weight and lower price make it ideal for first-time reel mower users or anyone mowing a postage-stamp yard.