American Lawn Mower Company 16-Inch 5-Bl vs Great States 815-18 18-Inch 5-Blade Push

Quick Verdict

Both mowers are high-quality manual reel options with strong customer ratings, but they serve slightly different needs. The American Lawn Mower Company 16-Inch 5-Blade Vintage Reel Lawn Mower is the better choice for smaller, well-maintained lawns where precision and a classic aesthetic matter. The Great States 815-18 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower offers a wider cutting path at a lower price, making it more efficient for medium-sized lawns on a budget.

Side-by-Side

Where American Lawn Mower Wins

• Build quality and materials: The American Lawn Mower Company model features a steel frame and a classic vintage design that often includes sealed ball-bearing wheels for smoother rolling. This translates to less maintenance and longer durability.
• Precision cutting: With a 16-inch cut width, it is slightly more maneuverable in tight spaces, flower beds, and around obstacles. The 5-blade reel produces a finer, scissor-like cut on grass up to 3-4 inches tall, especially if you mow frequently.
• Customer trust and history: With over 22,000 reviews, this mower has a proven track record. Many users note it handles uneven terrain better than budget reel mowers, and replacement parts are widely available.
• Aesthetic appeal: The vintage styling and green/red color scheme are a bonus for those who want a mower that looks as good as it performs.

Where Great States Wins

• Value for money: At $116, it is nearly $40 cheaper than the American model while offering a wider 18-inch cut. This makes it a more cost-effective choice for covering ground faster.
• Efficiency: The 18-inch cutting width reduces the number of passes needed, which is a clear advantage on lawns approaching 1/3 acre. You can finish mowing in less time.
• Lighter weight: The Great States mower is generally lighter, making it easier to push uphill or for users who prefer a less heavy machine. It also has a simpler design that is easy to assemble and adjust.
• Solid performance for the price: Despite the lower cost, it still uses a 5-blade reel and provides a clean cut on grass that is mowed regularly. Many users report it handles Bermuda and fescue well.

Which Should You Buy

Choose the American Lawn Mower Company 16-Inch if:

• Your lawn is small (under 1/4 acre) and has tight corners, pathways, or garden edges.
• You prioritize build quality, long-term durability, and a classic look.
• You want a mower with a reputation for smooth rolling and low maintenance over many years.
• You are willing to pay a premium for a more robust frame and sealed bearings.

Choose the Great States 815-18 if:

• Your lawn is medium-sized (1/4 to 1/3 acre) and you want to minimize mowing time.
• You are on a tighter budget and want the best value for a reliable reel mower.
• You prefer