American Lawn Mower Company 16-Inch 5-Bl vs Earthwise 1816-18EW 18-Inch 5-Blade Push
Quick Verdict
For most homeowners with small to medium flat lawns, the American Lawn Mower Company 16-Inch 5-Blade Vintage Reel Mower is the better choice. Its higher user rating (4.3 vs 4.2) from a massive 22,499 reviews indicates consistent reliability and satisfaction. The Earthwise 1816-18EW offers a slightly wider cut for less money, but the American model’s proven build quality and vintage design give it the edge for long-term use.
Side-by-Side
| Feature | American Lawn Mower 16-Inch | Earthwise 1816-18EW |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $154.00 | $129.89 |
| Cut Width | 16 inches | 18 inches |
| Blades | 5-blade reel | 5-blade reel |
| User Rating | 4.3/5 (22,499 reviews) | 4.2/5 (1,765 reviews) |
| Best Yard Size | Up to 0.25 acre | Up to 0.3 acre |
Where American Lawn Mower Wins
Build quality and reputation. With over 22,000 reviews and a 4.3 average, this mower has been tested by far more users. The vintage design typically uses heavier-gauge steel and a more durable reel assembly, which translates to longer life and cleaner cuts on grass up to 3-4 inches tall.
Easier maintenance. The American model’s 5-blade reel is known for staying sharp longer, and replacement parts (blades, wheels) are widely available. Its classic design also makes blade gap adjustment simpler for users who want to fine-tune cut quality.
Better for smaller, detailed lawns. The 16-inch width allows tighter trimming around flower beds, trees, and garden edges. If your lawn has many obstacles or narrow passages, the narrower cut is an advantage.
Where Earthwise Wins
Wider cut for the price. The 18-inch width covers 12.5% more grass per pass, making it faster on open lawns. At $129.89, it costs $24 less than the American model while offering a wider swath.
Lighter weight. The Earthwise is generally lighter (around 20 lbs vs 25+ lbs for the American), making it easier to push uphill or maneuver for users with less strength. Its grey plastic components also resist rust better in humid climates.
Better value for budget buyers. If you need to cover a slightly larger lawn (up to 0.3 acre) and want to spend under $130, the Earthwise provides a solid cut with fewer upfront costs. The 1,765 reviews still indicate good reliability for the price point.
Which Should You Buy
Choose the American Lawn Mower Company 16-Inch if:
- You prioritize long-term durability and proven performance
- Your lawn is under 0.25 acre with lots of obstacles
- You want a mower that holds its resale value and has easy parts availability
- You prefer the classic steel construction and vintage aesthetic
Choose the Earthwise 1816-18EW if:
- You’re on a strict budget and need to save $24
- Your lawn is more open and up to 0.3 acre (the 18-inch cut saves time)
- You want a lighter mower for hilly terrain or easy storage
- You live in a humid area where rust resistance matters
For most buyers, the American mower is the safer long-term investment. The Earthwise is a solid budget option that sacrifices some build quality for a wider cut and lower price.