American Lawn Mower Company 1415-16 16-I vs Great States 304-14 14-Inch 5-Blade Push

Quick Verdict

Both mowers are manual reel push mowers with 5-blade cutting reels and similar user ratings (4.3/5). The American Lawn Mower Company 1415-16 offers a wider 16-inch cutting path for larger lawns, while the Great States 304-14 is a narrower 14-inch model at a lower price point. For most homeowners with small to medium flat yards, the American mower provides better value due to its wider cut and higher overall user count. The Great States is best for very small lawns or tight budgets.

Side-by-Side

Where American Lawn Mower Wins

The American Lawn Mower Company 1415-16 wins on cutting efficiency and user trust. Its 16-inch cutting width is 2 inches wider than the Great States, meaning you cover 14% more grass per pass. This reduces mowing time noticeably on lawns over 2,000 square feet. The higher review count (22,499 vs. 9,257) indicates a much larger user base and long-term market presence, which often correlates with better reliability and parts availability. The mower also tends to have slightly sturdier construction, with a steel frame that holds up well to regular use. For yards with typical grass heights and moderate density, the wider cut makes this the more productive option.

Where Great States Wins

The Great States 304-14 wins on price and maneuverability. At $94.99, it costs $10 less than the American model, a 10% savings that matters for budget-conscious buyers. Its narrower 14-inch width makes it lighter (about 17 lbs vs. 22 lbs) and easier to push, turn, and store in tight spaces like narrow strips between flower beds or around trees. The smaller size also makes it a better fit for very small lawns (under 1,500 sq ft) where a wider mower would feel oversized. The red color adds visibility if you occasionally leave it in the yard. For those who prioritize low cost and light weight over cutting speed, the Great States is the practical choice.

Which Should You Buy

Choose the American Lawn Mower Company 1415-16 if: you have a lawn between 1/8 and 1/4 acre, want to finish mowing faster, or prefer a more robust build with a proven track record. The 16-inch cut is better for open, rectangular yards without many obstacles. It’s the better long-term investment for most homeowners.

Choose the Great States 304-14 if: your lawn is under 1,500 square feet, you have a very tight budget, or you need a lighter mower for easy lifting and storage. It’s also ideal for small, irregularly shaped spaces where the narrower width helps navigate tight corners and narrow paths.

For lawns larger than 1/4 acre, consider a gas or electric mower instead. Both reel mowers work best on flat, short grass and require regular blade sharpening.