Exmark 116-6350 Grass Bag Commercial Walk Behind Mower S Series Review

Here is a head-to-head comparison of the Exmark 116-6350 Grass Bag and the WORX WG163 Cordless String Trimmer.

Important Note: The Exmark listing at $69.99 is almost certainly an error (likely a replacement bag or part, not the full mower). A genuine Exmark S-Series commercial walk-behind mower costs $3,000–$5,000+. This comparison assumes the Exmark is a commercial-grade, gas-powered walk-behind mower (as its name implies), while the WORX is a consumer-grade electric string trimmer.

Quick Verdict

Exmark wins for large, demanding lawns and professional results; the WORX wins for small yards, edging, and budget-friendly convenience.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Where Exmark Wins

1. True Mowing Power & Speed
   The Exmark S-Series is a commercial zero-turn walk-behind with a powerful gas engine and a wide steel deck (36"–52"). It cuts grass fast—up to 8+ mph—and handles thick, wet, or tall grass without bogging down. The WORX is a string trimmer meant for light weeds and grass trimming, not full lawn mowing.

2. Superior Cut Quality & Bagging
   Exmark’s “UltraCut” series decks create a vacuum that lifts grass for a clean, even cut and efficient bagging. The included grass bag (the part listed at $69.99) is a high-capacity commercial bag. The WORX uses a string line that can tear or shred grass, leaving a ragged edge, and it has no bagging capability for clippings.

3. Durability & Longevity
   Built with a heavy-duty steel frame, commercial-grade engine, and serviceable parts, an Exmark S-Series can last 10–20 years with proper maintenance. The WORX is a lightweight plastic consumer tool designed for occasional use; its batteries degrade over 2–4 years.

Where WORX Wins

1. Price & Accessibility
   At $89.99 (with two batteries and a charger), the WORX is over 95% cheaper than a real Exmark. It’s an entry-level tool perfect for renters, small-lot homeowners, or anyone on a tight budget who just needs to trim edges and light weeds.

2. Versatility (Trimmer + Edger)
   The WORX WG163 easily converts from a string trimmer to a wheeled lawn edger with a simple button push. This makes it excellent for cleaning up fence lines, flower beds, and sidewalks—tasks the Exmark cannot do at all. It also weighs only 5.5 lbs, so it’s easy to carry and maneuver.

3. Low Maintenance & Quiet Operation
   No gas, no oil, no spark plugs, no carburetor cleaning. Just charge the batteries and pull the trigger. It runs at a low noise level (under 85 dB) and produces zero emissions, making it ideal for noise-sensitive neighborhoods and small yards where a gas mower is overkill.

Which Should You Buy?

Buy Mower A (Exmark S-Series) if:

• You have 1+ acres of lawn and need a fast, commercial-grade mower that can handle thick grass, hills, and daily use.
• You prioritize cut quality, bagging efficiency, and machine longevity over upfront cost.
• You are a landscaping professional or a serious homeowner willing to invest $3,000+ for a machine that lasts a decade or more.

Buy Mower B (WORX WG163) if:

• You own a small to medium lawn (under 0.5 acres) and need a lightweight, affordable tool for trimming and edging (not primary mowing).
• You want a low-maintenance, battery-powered option that’s quiet, emission-free, and easy to store.
• You are on a tight budget and need a reliable trimmer for occasional yard cleanups, but already own a separate mower for the main lawn.

Buy Neither if:

• You need a mid-range gas walk-behind mower for 0.5–1 acre. In that case, look at a Toro Timemaster or Honda HRX (around $600–$1,200). The Exmark is overkill, and the WORX is underpowered for mowing.

Here is a head-to-head comparison of the Exmark 116-6350 Grass Bag Commercial Walk Behind Mower S Series and the American Lawn Mower Company 1415-16 Reel Mower.

Quick Verdict

The American Lawn Mower Company reel mower wins for the vast majority of homeowners due to its proven reliability, zero operating costs, and simplicity, while the Exmark is only a better choice for a very specific, budget-constrained commercial need.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Important Note on the Exmark Listing: The $69.99 price is almost certainly for a replacement grass bag for an Exmark S Series mower, not a complete mower. A full Exmark S Series commercial walk-behind costs $4,000–$6,000. This comparison assumes the buyer is aware of this discrepancy, as a $70 commercial mower does not exist.

Where Exmark Wins

1. Extreme Cutting Capacity: The Exmark S Series is a commercial-grade, 36-inch wide, self-propelled machine. It can cut over 2 acres per hour, handling thick, wet, or overgrown grass that would instantly stop a reel mower. It is built for speed and volume.
2. Zero Operating Effort: Because it is a gas-powered, self-propelled mower (when fully assembled), the operator simply steers. There is no physical pushing required, making it suitable for large properties, hills, or users with physical limitations.
3. Mulching & Bagging Versatility: The Exmark S Series offers superior grass management. You can mulch heavy clippings, bag leaves in the fall, or side-discharge. The $70 bag is just one component of a highly versatile system.

Where American Lawn Mower Wins

1. True Cost & Maintenance: The American reel mower costs $105 and requires zero fuel, zero oil changes, zero spark plugs, and zero air filters. Its only maintenance is occasional blade sharpening (every 2-3 seasons). Over 5 years, the Exmark will cost thousands in fuel and service; the American costs nothing.
2. Reliability & Simplicity: With 22,499 reviews and a 4.3-star rating, this is one of the most proven lawn tools ever made. There is no engine to fail, no carburetor to clog, and no belt to break. It starts instantly, every time, with no pull cord.
3. Lawn Health & Quiet Operation: Reel mowers cut grass with a scissor-like action, resulting in a cleaner cut that heals faster and reduces browning. It is also nearly silent—you can mow at 6 AM without disturbing neighbors, and you get light exercise.

Which Should You Buy?

Buy Mower A (Exmark 116-6350 bag) if: You already own an Exmark S Series commercial mower and need a genuine replacement bag. This is not a mower purchase; it is a parts purchase for a professional landscaper who needs to keep a $5,000 machine running.

Buy Mower B (American Lawn Mower 1415-16) if: You own a small to medium lawn (under 1/4 acre), value quiet operation and zero fuel costs, and want a simple, reliable tool that will last for decades with minimal effort. It is the best choice for homeowners, renters, and anyone who dislikes engine maintenance.

Buy Neither if: You need a complete gas mower for a medium-sized lawn. In that case, buy a new $300–$500 self-propelled gas mower from Honda, Toro, or Craftsman. The Exmark “deal” is misleading, and the American reel mower is too narrow and slow for a 1/2-acre yard.