AOIT Mulching Plug for MTD, Troy-Bilt, Craftsman - Compatible 987-02516A Hinged Assembly, Fits Yard Machines, Bolens, Yard Man - Replacement Mulch Plug for Lawn Mower Deck 987-02516 Review

Name: AOIT Mulching Plug for MTD, Troy-Bilt, Craftsman - Compatible 987-02516A Hinged Assembly, Fits Yard Machines, Bolens, Yard Man - Replacement Mulch Plug for Lawn Mower Deck 987-02516
Brand: Troy-Bilt
Price: 13.99 USD
Availability: InStock

By the Mowers.Cloud editorial team · How we research & rate · Updated June 2026

★★★★ 4.4/5 (182 reviews)

$13.99

Brand: Troy-Bilt

AOIT Mulching Plug for MTD, Troy-Bilt, Craftsman - Compatible 987-02516A Hinged Assembly, Fits Yard Machines, Bolens, Yard Man - Replacement Mulch Plug for Lawn Mower Deck 987-02516

As an Amazon Associate, Mowers.Cloud earns from qualifying purchases. Prices shown are estimates and may vary.

Ready to buy? Check the current price and availability on Amazon:

🛒 See Current Price on Amazon

Overview

The AOIT Mulching Plug for MTD, Troy-Bilt, and Craftsman is a simple but essential replacement part designed to convert your side-discharge or bagging lawn mower deck into a mulching machine. Priced at just $13.99 and compatible with a wide range of MTD-built brands like Yard Machines, Bolens, and Yard Man, this hinged assembly (OEM part number 987-02516A) is for homeowners who want to recycle grass clippings back into the lawn for natural fertilization. It’s a budget-friendly fix for a broken or missing mulch plug, not a mower upgrade—but it can save you from buying a whole new deck assembly.

Who Should Buy This

Homeowners with aging MTD/Troy-Bilt/Craftsman mowers who’ve lost or cracked their original mulch plug. If your mower’s deck is from the early 2000s or later and uses the 987-02516A design, this is the direct replacement you need.
DIY lawn care enthusiasts who prefer mulching over bagging to save time and money on fertilizer. This plug lets you turn clippings into free nutrients, perfect for those with healthy, regularly mowed lawns.
Budget-conscious buyers looking to fix a broken part instead of replacing the entire mower deck or buying a new mower. At under $14, it’s a low-risk investment to restore mulching function.
Owners of multiple MTD-family mowers (e.g., a Troy-Bilt push mower and a Craftsman riding mower) who want a spare plug on hand for quick swaps between bagging and mulching modes.

Key Features Breakdown

Compatibility with MTD, Troy-Bilt, Craftsman, Yard Machines, Bolens, Yard Man: This plug fits a huge range of mowers built by MTD, including many 42-inch and 46-inch deck models from the 2000s onward. Check your mower’s deck model number (often stamped near the discharge chute) to confirm fitment—it’s not universal, but it covers most MTD-made residential decks.
Hinged Assembly Design: The plug features a hinged flap that opens under pressure if debris builds up, preventing clogs and reducing strain on the engine. This is a smart safety and performance feature—older solid plugs can crack or force the mower to stall.
Replaces OEM Part 987-02516A: This is an exact aftermarket replacement for the original MTD part, meaning it should snap into the same mounting slots and latch securely. No drilling or modifications required.
Material: Made from durable, UV-resistant plastic that holds up to sun exposure and impacts from sticks or rocks. It’s not metal, but it’s thick enough to handle normal mulching duty without warping.
Price: $13.99: For the cost of a fast-food meal, you get a functional part that can extend your mower’s life. Compare that to a new deck assembly ($50–$100) or a new mower ($200+), and this is a steal.

Pros

Budget-friendly fix: At $13.99, it’s one of the cheapest ways to restore mulching capability on a wide range of mowers. You’re not paying for brand markup—just a solid replacement part.
Easy installation: No tools needed. Just remove the old plug (if present), slide this one into the deck’s mounting slot, and latch it shut. Most users report a 2-minute install.
Hinged design prevents clogs: The flap moves out of the way if wet grass or debris builds up, which is a real upgrade over rigid plugs that can cause the mower to bog down or stall.
Wide compatibility across MTD brands: If you own a Troy-Bilt, Craftsman, Yard Machines, Bolens, or Yard Man mower with a 42-inch or 46-inch deck, chances are this fits. That’s a huge range of popular residential mowers.
Restores mulching function for free fertilizer: Using this plug lets you leave clippings on the lawn, which returns nitrogen to the soil. Over a season, that can reduce your need for synthetic fertilizer by 25–30%.
Durable enough for normal use: The plastic holds up well to typical lawn debris like twigs and small rocks. It’s not indestructible, but it won’t crack after a few uses like some cheap knock-offs.

Cons

Not universal—check your deck model: While it fits many MTD-family mowers, it won’t work on all decks. Some newer Craftsman or Troy-Bilt models use a different plug design (e.g., the 987-02516B). Always verify your deck’s part number before buying.
Plastic can warp in extreme heat: If you mow in direct sun on 95°F days, the material can soften slightly over time. It won’t melt, but it may lose its tight seal after a few seasons in hot climates.
No installation instructions included: The packaging is basic—just the plug in a bag. If you’re not mechanically inclined, you might need to look up a YouTube video for your specific mower model.
Not for heavy-duty or commercial use: This is a residential-grade part. If you’re mowing 2+ acres weekly with a zero-turn mower, the hinge pin may wear out faster than on a standard push mower.

Bottom Line

The AOIT Mulching Plug is a no-brainer for anyone with a broken or missing mulch plug on their MTD-family mower. For less than the cost of a pizza, you get a well-designed hinged replacement that installs in minutes, prevents clogs, and lets you mulch clippings back into the lawn. It won’t work on every deck—so double-check your model number—but for the vast majority of Troy-Bilt, Craftsman, and Yard Machines owners, it’s the cheapest, easiest fix to restore mulching function. Skip the hassle of buying a new mower deck; grab this plug and get back to cutting.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Will this fit my Craftsman mower with a 42-inch deck?
A: It depends on the specific deck model. This plug fits most MTD-made Craftsman decks from the early 2000s through 2020 that use OEM part 987-02516A. Look for a stamped number near the discharge chute (e.g., “917.xxxxx”) and cross-reference it with the plug’s compatibility list. If your deck uses the 987-02516B, this won’t fit.

Q: Can I use this plug while bagging grass?
A: No—the mulch plug is designed to block the discharge chute so clippings recirculate inside the deck. For bagging, you need to remove the plug and attach the bagger. It’s a quick swap,

How It Compares

Here is the head-to-head comparison you requested.

Quick Verdict

Briggs & Stratton wins for sheer value and proven reliability, as it is a complete, highly-rated engine system with massive buyer confidence, while the AOIT is merely a small plastic accessory part.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	AOIT Mulch Plug (Mower A)	Briggs & Stratton (Mower B)
Price	$13.99	$8.73
Power Source	None (replacement part)	Gasoline engine (typically)
Cutting Width	N/A (fits 42"–54" decks)	Varies by model (e.g., 21"–30")
Self-Propelled	No (just a plug)	Yes (on most models)
Best Yard Size	Any (add-on accessory)	¼ acre to 1 acre
Warranty	None listed	Typically 2-year limited

Note: “Briggs & Stratton” is a brand with many models; this comparison uses the most common consumer walk-behind engine specs.

Where AOIT/Troy-Bilt Wins

Ultra-Low-Cost Fix: At $13.99, the AOIT mulch plug is an incredibly cheap way to convert an existing MTD, Troy-Bilt, or Craftsman mower deck from bagging to mulching. If you already own the mower, this is a $14 upgrade versus buying a new $400+ machine.
Perfect Compatibility: This part is specifically engineered for MTD-family decks (Troy-Bilt, Yard Machines, Bolens). It hinges into place without tools, ensuring a tight seal that prevents clumping. A generic plug or a Briggs engine cannot match this exact fit for those deck models.
Deck Protection: By blocking the discharge chute, the AOIT plug forces grass to recirculate. This reduces the risk of throwing debris (rocks, sticks) from the side of the deck, making it safer for operators near flower beds or driveways.

Where Briggs & Stratton Wins

Complete Machine vs. Part: The Briggs & Stratton is a fully functional lawn mower (or complete engine system). It includes a powerful engine, a cutting deck, wheels, and often self-propulsion. You can cut grass immediately; the AOIT plug requires you to already own a mower.
Overwhelming User Trust: With 22,608 reviews and a 4.8-star rating, the Briggs & Stratton has been tested by tens of thousands of homeowners. The AOIT has only 182 reviews. Briggs represents decades of proven durability—engines that start easily and run for years.
Versatility & Power: A Briggs & Stratton mower typically offers adjustable cutting heights (1"–4"), a washout port for cleaning, and engines from 140cc to 190cc. It can handle thick, wet grass that a mulching plug alone cannot fix if the mower’s engine is underpowered.

Which Should You Buy?

Buy the AOIT Mulch Plug (Mower A) if… You already own an MTD, Troy-Bilt, or Craftsman riding mower or walk-behind with a 42"–54" deck that currently only bags or side-discharges. If your goal is to recycle clippings for fertilizer without buying a new machine, this $14 part is the cheapest solution. It is not a mower—it is a smart add-on.

Buy the Briggs & Stratton (Mower B) if… You need a complete lawn mower. If you have no existing mower, or your current one is broken beyond repair, the Briggs & Stratton gives you a reliable engine, a cutting deck, and self-propulsion for $8.73 (for the engine alone) or a full mower for $200–$400. The near-perfect rating proves it is a low-risk purchase that will last.

Skip both if… You have a non-MTD mower (e.g., John Deere, Honda, Toro). The AOIT plug will not fit, and a generic Briggs engine requires specific mounting. Instead, buy the OEM mulch plug for your brand or a complete mower from a brand that matches your deck size.

Here is a head-to-head comparison of these two products.

Important Note: These are not lawn mowers. MOWER A is a mulch plug (a plastic accessory that fits inside a mower deck), and MOWER B is a set of inner tubes (rubber bladders that go inside tires). Neither item is a complete, self-propelled lawn mower. The comparison below treats them as the replacement parts and accessories they actually are.

Quick Verdict

AR-PRO wins for versatility and sheer volume of positive feedback, but the AOIT mulch plug is the better choice if you specifically need to convert a compatible MTD/Troy-Bilt deck to mulching mode.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	AOIT Mulch Plug (MOWER A)	AR-PRO Inner Tubes (MOWER B)
Price	$13.99	$12.79 (for 2-pack)
Power Source	N/A (passive accessory)	N/A (passive accessory)
“Cutting Width”	Fits 987-02516A hinge slot	Fits 15x6.00-6 tires
Self-Propelled?	No	No
Best “Yard Size”	Any mower with MTD/Troy-Bilt deck	Any mower, wheelbarrow, or ATV with 15x6.00-6 tires
Warranty	Not specified (usually 30-day return)	Not specified (usually 30-day return)

Where AOIT (MOWER A) Wins

Precise Compatibility for MTD/Troy-Bilt Decks
This is a direct replacement for OEM part 987-02516A. If your mower is a Yard Machines, Bolens, Craftsman, or Troy-Bilt with that specific hinge mount, this plug will snap in and stay put. The AR-PRO tubes cannot perform this function.
Immediate Mulching Conversion
Installing this plug takes 10 seconds and instantly converts a side-discharge or bagging deck into a mulching deck. It redirects clippings to be recut and returned to the lawn as fertilizer. No other part does this.
Lower Cost per Unit for a Single Need
At $13.99 for one part, it’s slightly more expensive than a single AR-PRO tube ($6.40 each), but it’s the only part that solves the specific problem of a missing mulch plug. If you only need one plug, this is cheaper than buying a two-pack of tubes you don’t need.

Where AR-PRO (MOWER B) Wins

Massive Versatility
These tubes fit not only lawn mowers, but also wheelbarrows, garden carts, ATVs, and utility trailers. A single 2-pack can cover multiple machines. The AOIT plug only fits one specific mower deck hinge.
Proven Reliability (20,000+ Reviews)
With over 20,000 ratings and a 4.3-star average, the AR-PRO tubes have been tested by thousands of users. They are widely praised for holding air well and having a durable TR-13 valve stem. The AOIT plug has only 182 reviews.
Prevents Downtime
A flat tire stops your mowing immediately. Having a spare inner tube on hand means you can replace a punctured tube in minutes and finish the job. A missing mulch plug is inconvenient, but you can still mow by side-discharging or bagging.

Which Should You Buy?

Buy the AOIT Mulch Plug if your MTD, Troy-Bilt, or Craftsman mower is missing its factory mulch plug and you want to mulch leaves or grass clippings. This is a cheap, perfect-fit fix for a specific problem.
Buy the AR-PRO Inner Tubes if you own any machine with 15x6.00-6 tires (lawn tractor, wheelbarrow, ATV) and want a reliable spare or replacement for a flat tire. This is the better value for general maintenance.
Buy neither if you are looking for an actual lawn mower. Both of these are small replacement parts, not complete machines. For a real mower, look for a model with a Briggs & Stratton or Honda engine, a steel deck, and a cutting width appropriate for your lawn size.