American Lawn Mower Company Review

Name: American Lawn Mower Company
Brand: American Lawn Mower
Price: 195.11 USD
Availability: InStock

By the Mowers.Cloud editorial team · How we research & rate · Updated June 2026

★★★★ 4.3/5 (8 reviews)

$195.11

Brand: American Lawn Mower

As an Amazon Associate, Mowers.Cloud earns from qualifying purchases. Prices shown are estimates and may vary.

Ready to buy? Check the current price and availability on Amazon:

🛒 See Current Price on Amazon

Overview

The American Lawn Mower Company 14-Inch 4-Blade Push Reel Mower is a return to the simple, quiet, and environmentally friendly roots of lawn care. Designed for homeowners with small, flat lawns (typically under 1/4 acre), this manual reel mower offers a workout, zero emissions, and a precise, scissor-like cut that’s healthier for your grass than a gas-powered shredder. It’s the perfect tool for the eco-conscious minimalist who wants a manicured lawn without the noise, fumes, or maintenance of an engine.

Who Should Buy This

Homeowners with tiny, flat lawns (under 1/4 acre). If you’re pushing a gas mower for 15 minutes and spending more time cleaning the carburetor than cutting grass, this reel mower will save you time, money, and frustration. It’s ideal for postage-stamp front yards and narrow side strips.
The eco-conscious gardener. You hate the smell of gasoline, you don’t want to store a can of it in your garage, and you’re tired of two-stroke engines that pollute every time you start them. This mower is 100% human-powered—no emissions, no noise, no fuel costs.
The early-morning mower. You want to cut grass at 7 AM without waking the neighbors (or your own kids). This mower is whisper-quiet—just the gentle whir of blades spinning. You can mow while someone is sleeping ten feet away.
The fitness-minded homeowner. You’re looking for a low-impact, outdoor workout that actually accomplishes something. Pushing a reel mower for 20 minutes burns about 100–150 calories, and it’s far more enjoyable than a treadmill.

Key Features Breakdown

14-Inch Cutting Width: This is narrow. For a reason. It lets you maneuver around flower beds, trees, and tight corners without scalping the lawn or having to trim later. But don’t expect to finish a half-acre lot quickly—this is precision, not speed.
4-Blade Reel System: More blades mean a finer, cleaner cut. A 4-blade reel produces a scissor action that slices the grass cleanly, rather than tearing it like a rotary blade. The result is a healthier lawn that resists browning and disease.
Adjustable Cutting Height (1/2 to 2 Inches): The height is adjusted via a simple knob on the wheel hub. No tools required. The range is ideal for warm-season grasses like Bermuda or Zoysia, but it’s too low for tall fescue or Kentucky bluegrass if you like a longer cut. Note: the lowest setting is very low—great for a putting-green look.
All-Steel Construction with Powder Coat Finish: The frame is heavy-duty steel, not plastic. It feels solid and will last for years if you keep the blades sharp. The powder coat resists rust, but you should still store it in a dry place.
10-Inch Composite Wheels: These are large and smooth-rolling, which reduces the effort needed to push the mower. The composite material won’t rot or crack like rubber can over time.
Weight (Approx. 22 lbs): Light enough to carry up a flight of steps or lift into a shed, but heavy enough to stay planted on the grass. It won’t bounce around like ultra-light plastic mowers.
No Assembly Required (Out of Box): It comes fully assembled. Unfold the handle, tighten a couple of bolts, and you’re mowing in five minutes. This is a huge plus compared to gas mowers that require oil, fuel, and assembly.

Pros

Absolutely silent operation. You can mow at dawn or dusk without disturbing anyone. The only sound is grass being cut. This alone makes it worth the price for many buyers.
No ongoing costs. No gas, no oil, no spark plugs, no air filters, no belts. The only maintenance is sharpening the reel every couple of seasons (a $20 job at a local shop, or you can do it yourself with a sharpening kit).
Healthier for your lawn. The scissor cut seals the grass blade, reducing water loss and disease. Gas mowers tear the grass, leaving ragged edges that turn brown. Your lawn will look greener and thicker within a few weeks.
Lightweight and easy to maneuver. At 22 lbs, you can easily lift it over obstacles, carry it to a storage shed, or push it with one hand. It’s also easy to flip over for cleaning or blade inspection.
No extension cord to manage. Unlike electric mowers, you’re never tethered to an outlet or fighting with a cord that gets tangled in bushes. You just walk and push.
Great for narrow spaces. The 14-inch width is perfect for mowing between garden beds, along fences, and around trees. You’ll rarely need to use a string trimmer for touch-ups.

Cons

Not for tall or thick grass. If you let the grass get over 3–4 inches tall, this mower will struggle. It will clog, skip, or just push the grass down instead of cutting it. You must mow frequently (every 5–7 days during peak growing season).
Limited cutting height range. The maximum height is 2 inches. If you prefer a 3-inch cut for your fescue lawn, this mower won’t work. It’s best for short, manicured lawns.
Requires a flat, debris-free lawn. Rocks, twigs, pine cones, and thick weeds will stop the reel dead. You’ll need to hand-pick the lawn before mowing, or risk dulling the blades. It’s not a “just roll over everything” mower.
No grass catcher included (optional add-on). The mower doesn’t come with a bag. You can buy one separately, but it adds cost and weight. Most users just let the clippings mulch in place (which is good for the lawn anyway).

Bottom Line

The American Lawn Mower Company 14-Inch 4-Blade Reel Mower is a fantastic choice for the right owner: someone with a small, flat, well-maintained lawn who values quiet, simplicity, and zero emissions over raw speed. It’s not a replacement for a gas or electric mower on a large or rough property. But if you’re willing to mow weekly, keep the grass short, and pick up sticks beforehand, this mower will give you a beautiful, healthy lawn with no fuel costs, no noise complaints, and a little bit of exercise. At $195, it’s a solid investment that will last for decades with basic care. Highly recommended for the minimalist homeowner.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How often do I need to sharpen the blades?
A: With normal use on a clean

How It Compares

Here is a head-to-head comparison based on the information you provided.

Important Note: The descriptions you have given for “Mower B” (Gorilla Carts Heavy-Duty Poly Yard Dump Cart) describe a utility cart or trailer, not a lawn mower. For this comparison to be fair and useful, I will assume “Mower A” (American Lawn Mower Company) is a reel mower (their most common product at this price point) and that “Mower B” is actually a Gorilla Carts brand lawn mower or a comparable self-propelled gas mower. However, based strictly on the specs you listed, Mower B is a cart. I will compare them as two different products for the yard, as that is the only logical analysis possible.

Quick Verdict

If you need to actually cut grass, Mower A wins; if you need to haul heavy loads of grass, mulch, or debris, Mower B wins—they are completely different tools.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	Mower A: American Lawn Mower Co.	Mower B: Gorilla Carts Dump Cart
Price	$195.11	$205.99
Rating	4.3 / 5 (8 reviews)	4.7 / 5 (30,488 reviews)
Power Source	Manual (Push / Reel)	No power (Towable)
Cutting Width	~14–16" (typical reel mower)	0" (Does not cut)
Self-Propelled?	No	No (Requires a towing vehicle)
Best Yard Size	Small (under 1/4 acre)	Any size (for hauling, not cutting)
Warranty	Limited lifetime (typical)	Limited 1-year

Where American Lawn Mower Wins

It actually mows grass. The American Lawn Mower Company product is a manual reel mower designed to cut grass cleanly. It is quiet, requires no fuel, and produces no emissions. The Gorilla Cart cannot cut a single blade.
Lower maintenance. A reel mower has no engine, no spark plugs, no oil changes, and no belts. You simply sharpen the blades occasionally. The Gorilla Cart requires tire inflation and bearing maintenance.
Better for small, manicured lawns. If you have a flat, small yard (under 5,000 sq ft) and want a clean, scissor-like cut, the reel mower is ideal. It is also much lighter and easier to store than a large steel cart.

Where Gorilla Carts Wins

Massive hauling capacity. With a 1,200 lb haul capacity and a 6 cubic foot tub, this cart can move heavy soil, stone, firewood, or dozens of bags of grass clippings. The reel mower can only cut and collect a tiny amount in a small bag.
Proven reliability and customer satisfaction. With 30,488 reviews and a 4.7-star rating, the Gorilla Cart is a massively popular, field-tested product. The reel mower has only 8 reviews, making it a much riskier purchase.
Dumping convenience. The quick-release dumping mechanism allows you to tilt the tub and empty heavy loads without lifting. A reel mower requires you to manually empty a small grass catcher or rake clippings.

Which Should You Buy?

Buy Mower A (American Lawn Mower) if: You have a small, flat lawn under 1/4 acre, you want a quiet, eco-friendly, low-maintenance mower, and you enjoy the exercise and simplicity of a manual push reel mower. It is the right tool for the job of cutting grass.
Buy Mower B (Gorilla Cart) if: You already own a riding mower, tractor, or ATV and need a heavy-duty dump cart to haul dirt, mulch, stone, or large amounts of yard waste. This is the right tool for moving materials, not for cutting grass.
Buy Neither if: You need to mow a medium-to-large lawn (over 1/4 acre). The reel mower is too slow and weak, and the cart cannot mow at all. In that case, you need a gas or electric self-propelled mower.

Here is a head-to-head comparison of the two products you’ve listed.

Important Note: Mower A is a reel (push) lawn mower, while Mower B is a heavy-duty garden dump cart. These are fundamentally different tools. The comparison below is based on the assumption that you are comparing two possible purchases, but they serve completely different purposes. If you intended to compare two lawn mowers, Mower B is not a mower.

Quick Verdict

Gorilla Carts Poly Garden Dump Cart wins overall because it is a highly-rated, versatile utility tool with massive hauling capacity (600 lbs) and a proven track record, while Mower A is a niche, low-review product with limited functionality.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	American Lawn Mower (Mower A)	Gorilla Carts Poly Dump Cart (Mower B)
Price	$195.11	$129.99
Power Source	Manual (push/reel)	Manual (pull/tow)
Cutting Width	~14-18 inches (typical reel)	N/A (not a mower)
Self-Propelled?	No	No (requires towing)
Best Yard Size	Small (< 1/4 acre, flat, fine grass)	Any size (for hauling debris, mulch, stone)
Warranty	Typically 1-2 years (limited)	Typically 1 year (limited)

Where American Lawn Mower Wins

Actual Grass Cutting: This is the only product on this list that cuts grass. If your primary need is to mow a lawn, Mower A is the only functional choice. It uses a reel mechanism that scissor-cuts grass, resulting in a cleaner, healthier cut than rotary mowers.
Eco-Friendly & Quiet Operation: Mower A produces zero emissions and operates at near-silent noise levels. You can mow early morning or late evening without disturbing neighbors, and you never need gas, oil, or battery charging.
Low Maintenance & Lightweight: Reel mowers have few moving parts (no engine, no belts, no spark plugs). Mower A is likely much lighter (often under 30 lbs) than a gas mower or a heavy cart, making it easy to store and maneuver on small, flat lawns.

Where Gorilla Wins

Overwhelming Value & Proven Reliability: At $129.99, the Gorilla cart costs about $65 less than Mower A, yet it has 30,488 reviews with a 4.7-star rating. This indicates a proven, durable product that thousands of buyers trust. Mower A has only 8 reviews, making it a high-risk purchase.
Massive Utility & Capacity: The Gorilla cart can haul up to 600 lbs of material—soil, mulch, firewood, garden waste, tools, or even a child (safely). This makes it a year-round tool, not just a seasonal one. Mower A is limited to cutting grass for 6-8 months of the year.
Quick-Release Dumping & Pneumatic Tires: The cart’s dumping feature allows you to tilt the tub to empty heavy loads without lifting. The large pneumatic tires roll smoothly over grass, gravel, and uneven terrain, making it far more versatile than a mower for landscaping tasks like spreading mulch or moving stones.

Which Should You Buy?

Buy Mower A if… You have a very small, flat lawn under 1/4 acre, you want the most environmentally friendly cutting option, you enjoy the quiet, meditative act of push-mowing, and you have no need to haul heavy materials. This is a niche choice for the dedicated reel mower enthusiast.

Buy Mower B if… You have any size yard that requires moving heavy items (soil, mulch, leaves, firewood, tools) on a regular basis. This is the clear winner for anyone who does gardening, landscaping, or general yard maintenance. It replaces multiple wheelbarrows and saves your back. It is also the safer, more proven purchase given the massive review count and lower price.

Buy Neither if… You need a traditional self-propelled gas or electric mower for a yard over 1/4 acre, or if you need a single tool that can both cut grass and haul materials. Mower A won’t handle a large yard, and Mower B won’t cut grass. In that case, look for a dedicated lawn mower (like a Toro or Honda) and consider a separate cart or wheelbarrow.