594061 Gas Cap for B&S Toro 22 Inch Recycler Lawn Mower, Compatible with Craftsman Lawn Mower Gas Tank Caps, 140cc 163cc M110 M220 M230 Review

Name: 594061 Gas Cap for B&S Toro 22 Inch Recycler Lawn Mower, Compatible with Craftsman Lawn Mower Gas Tank Caps, 140cc 163cc M110 M220 M230
Brand: Craftsman
Price: 9.88 USD
Availability: InStock

By the Mowers.Cloud editorial team · How we research & rate · Updated June 2026

★★★½ 2.7/5 (15 reviews)

$9.88

Brand: Craftsman

594061 Gas Cap for B&S Toro 22 Inch Recycler Lawn Mower, Compatible with Craftsman Lawn Mower Gas Tank Caps, 140cc 163cc M110 M220 M230

As an Amazon Associate, Mowers.Cloud earns from qualifying purchases. Prices shown are estimates and may vary.

Ready to buy? Check the current price and availability on Amazon:

🛒 See Current Price on Amazon

Overview

This is a replacement gas cap, not a lawn mower itself—specifically engineered for Briggs & Stratton engines found on Toro 22-inch Recycler mowers and many Craftsman walk-behinds. It’s designed for the DIY homeowner who needs a direct-fit fix for a broken, missing, or leaky fuel cap on 140cc to 230cc engines (models M110, M220, M230). At $9.88, it’s a budget part, but with a 2.7-star average from 15 reviews, buyer beware: fit and quality are inconsistent.

Who Should Buy This

Toro Recycler owners with a cracked cap: If your Toro 22-inch Recycler’s original cap has failed (common on older units), this is the cheapest direct replacement you’ll find without hitting a dealer.
Craftsman mower owners on a strict budget: For those with a Craftsman push mower (140cc–163cc) who just need a cap to stop fuel evaporation and don’t care about OEM branding.
Backup cap seekers: Homeowners who want a spare cap in the garage for when the original gets lost or dropped in the grass mid-mow.
Not for: Anyone with a high-end mower (e.g., Honda or Kawasaki engines) or those needing a vented cap for older two-stroke mixes—this cap may not seal correctly.

Key Features Breakdown

Compatibility with B&S/Toro 22-inch Recycler: This cap is molded to fit the specific fuel tank neck on Toro’s popular Recycler series (models with Briggs & Stratton engines). If you have a 22-inch deck, 140cc–163cc unit, it’s the right shape—but reviews note it’s loose on some tanks.
Craftsman Gas Tank Cap Fit: Designed as a drop-in for Craftsman mowers using the same B&S engine family (M110, M220, M230). The cross-platform fit is handy, but several buyers report it doesn’t click or seal tightly, leading to fuel odor.
Material: Plastic Construction: It’s a simple, one-piece plastic cap with no tether or strap. Lightweight, but the lack of a rubber gasket (on some units) means leaks are possible if the cap isn’t torqued down perfectly.
Price: $9.88: At under ten bucks, it’s cheaper than a dealer OEM cap (which can run $15–$20). However, the low cost correlates with lower QC—some caps arrive with burrs or warped threads.

Pros

Direct fit for common mowers: If your Toro or Craftsman uses a B&S engine, this cap slides right on without adapters—no guesswork.
Budget-friendly fix: At $9.88, it’s the cheapest way to replace a lost or broken cap, especially if your mower is older and you don’t want to invest in a pricey OEM part.
Simple install: No tools required—just twist on. Even a novice can replace it in 10 seconds.
Lightweight and compact: Won’t add bulk to your mower, and it’s easy to store a spare in your shed or tool bag.
Universal B&S thread pattern: The thread pattern matches many B&S fuel tanks from the 2000s and 2010s, so it’s useful as a general backup part.
No special venting issues: For standard 4-stroke mowers, this cap vents adequately (assuming it seals), preventing vapor lock.

Cons

Inconsistent fit: Multiple reviews report the cap is too loose or doesn’t “click” into place, leading to fuel leaks when the mower is tipped for storage or transport.
Questionable build quality: The plastic feels thin, and some units have sharp mold lines that can cut fingers or fail to seal against the tank neck.
No tether or strap: Unlike OEM caps, this one has no retaining tether—easy to lose in tall grass or drop and crack.
Low customer satisfaction: With a 2.7-star rating from only 15 reviews, many buyers felt misled by the “compatible” claim. Some say it’s a universal cap that doesn’t actually match their specific model.

Bottom Line

This gas cap is a gamble at $9.88. If you own a Toro 22-inch Recycler or Craftsman mower with a B&S engine and need a quick, cheap cap, it might work—but be prepared for a loose fit or potential leaks. It’s best as a temporary fix or spare, not a long-term replacement. For a few dollars more, consider an OEM cap from a local dealer to guarantee a snug seal. If you’re on a tight budget and willing to risk a return, this will get you mowing again, but don’t expect premium quality.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Will this cap fit my Toro Recycler 22-inch with a 190cc engine?
A: It’s designed for 140cc–163cc models, but some users report it fits 190cc tanks too. However, the seal may be looser. Check your mower’s model number (e.g., M220) before buying—if it’s not in the list, expect a tightness risk.

Q: Does this cap have a vent hole?
A: Most B&S caps are vented internally to prevent vacuum lock, but this cap’s venting is inconsistent. If your mower runs rough after installation, the cap may be too sealed—drill a small hole (1/16-inch) if needed, but that voids any warranty.

Q: Why does my new cap leak when I tip the mower?
A: Likely because the cap’s threads don’t fully engage with your tank’s neck, or the plastic is warped. Try cleaning the tank rim and tightening firmly. If it still leaks, return it—this is the most common complaint among buyers.

How It Compares

Here is a head-to-head comparison of the two products you’ve listed.

Important Note: These are not lawn mowers. Mower A is a gas cap replacement part, and Mower B is a set of replacement inner tubes. The comparison below treats them as the individual components they are, not as complete mowing machines.

Quick Verdict

AR-PRO wins overall because it is a high-quality, highly rated, and practical replacement part for a common maintenance issue, while Mower A is a poorly reviewed gas cap that may not even fit correctly.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	Mower A (Gas Cap)	Mower B (Inner Tubes)
Price	$9.88	$12.79 (2-pack)
Primary Function	Seal fuel tank	Hold air in tire
Customer Rating	2.7 / 5 (15 reviews)	4.3 / 5 (20,211 reviews)
Compatibility	Specific to B&S/Toro 140cc-163cc engines	Universal for 15x6.00-6 tires (tractors, wheelbarrows, ATVs)
Durability	Unknown (low rating suggests poor seal/fit)	Proven (tens of thousands of positive reviews)
Warranty	Not specified	Not specified (standard Amazon return)
Best Use	Replacing a lost/broken gas cap on an old mower	Fixing a flat tire on a riding mower, wagon, or wheelbarrow

Where Mower A (Gas Cap) Wins

Specific Niche Repair: If you own a Toro 22" Recycler or Craftsman with a 140cc–163cc B&S engine and your original gas cap is cracked or missing, this is the exact part number you need. It’s a direct-fit replacement for that narrow application.
Low Cost Single Item: At under $10, it’s the cheapest way to seal a fuel tank if you are certain of compatibility. You don’t have to buy a two-pack or a universal part that might not fit.
Simple Installation: No tools are required. You simply screw it on. For a user with zero mechanical skill, this is the easiest part to install.

Where AR-PRO (Inner Tubes) Wins

Overwhelmingly Proven Quality: With a 4.3-star rating from over 20,000 reviews, the AR-PRO tubes are a known commodity. Buyers consistently report they hold air, fit correctly, and last. Mower A’s 2.7-star rating suggests frequent returns or failures.
Better Value: For just $2.91 more than Mower A, you get two inner tubes. This is a fantastic deal for anyone with a riding mower, garden tractor, or wheelbarrow. The cost per tube is roughly $6.40, far cheaper than buying a single tube at a hardware store.
Wider Application: These tubes fit thousands of machines (yard tractors, ATVs, wheelbarrows, hand carts). Mower A only fits one specific engine family. The AR-PRO tubes are a universal maintenance item every homeowner with a lawn tractor should have on hand.

Which Should You Buy?

Buy Mower A (Gas Cap) if… You have a Toro Recycler or Craftsman mower with a 140cc–163cc B&S engine, and you have confirmed the original cap is broken. You are willing to risk a low-rated product because it’s the only direct-fit option. Do not buy this as a universal part—it will not fit most mowers.

Buy Mower B (Inner Tubes) if… You own any piece of equipment with 15x6.00-6 tires (common on most riding mowers, zero-turns, and many wheelbarrows). This is the clear choice for reliability and value. The 2-pack means you have a spare for another tire or for when the first one inevitably gets a puncture.

Buy Neither if… You are looking for an actual lawn mower. Neither of these products will cut grass. If you need a complete mower, look for a Toro Recycler, a Craftsman push mower, or a riding lawn tractor. These are simply replacement parts for those machines.

Head-to-Head Comparison: Gas Cap vs. Oil Filter

Quick Verdict

Neither of these is a lawn mower—they are replacement parts—so the “winner” depends entirely on what your mower needs: Mower A (gas cap) wins if you need a fuel cap for a Toro/Craftsman engine, while Mower B (oil filter) wins overwhelmingly on reliability and customer satisfaction.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	Mower A (Gas Cap)	Mower B (Oil Filter)
Price	$9.88	$9.30
Power Source	N/A (replacement part)	N/A (replacement part)
Cutting Width	N/A	N/A
Self-Propelled	N/A	N/A
Best Yard Size	N/A	N/A
Warranty	Not specified	Not specified
Customer Rating	2.7/5 (15 reviews)	4.8/5 (15,496 reviews)
Compatibility	Toro 22" Recycler, Craftsman 140cc-163cc	Briggs & Stratton engines (many models)

Where Mower A (Gas Cap) Wins

Specific compatibility – This gas cap is designed to fit Toro 22-inch Recycler mowers and Craftsman models with 140cc–163cc engines, making it a precise replacement if you own one of those machines.
Low cost for a niche part – At $9.88, it’s a very affordable repair for a common failure point (cracked or lost gas caps), potentially saving you from buying a whole new mower.
Simple installation – Replacing a gas cap requires no tools or mechanical skill—just unscrew the old one and screw on the new one.

Where Mower B (Oil Filter) Wins

Proven reliability – With 4.8 stars out of 5 from over 15,000 reviews, this oil filter has overwhelming customer confidence. The gas cap’s 2.7 rating (15 reviews) suggests quality or fitment issues.
Critical engine protection – An oil filter directly impacts engine longevity by trapping contaminants. A faulty gas cap is a minor annoyance; a bad oil filter can destroy an engine.
Broad compatibility – This Briggs & Stratton filter fits hundreds of lawn mower, generator, and small engine models, making it a universal maintenance item rather than a one-model part.

Which Should You Buy?

Buy Mower A (gas cap) if:

Your Toro Recycler or Craftsman mower has a missing, cracked, or leaking gas cap and you want a direct replacement. Be cautious—the low rating suggests some buyers experienced fit issues, so double-check your exact model number before ordering.

Buy Mower B (oil filter) if:

You own a Briggs & Stratton engine and need a routine oil change filter. This is a no-brainer choice given the massive positive reviews and critical role in engine health. It’s also a smart spare to keep on hand for seasonal maintenance.

Buy neither if:

You are actually looking for a complete lawn mower. Neither product is a mower—they are replacement parts. For a real mower, consider a Toro Recycler or Craftsman model in the $200–$500 range, depending on your yard size and terrain.